‘Titanic’ Makers Apologize to Hero’s Hometown

By admin

By Helen Smith

LONDON (Reuters) – The makers of the film “Titanic” have apologized to a Scottish town for turning its local hero into a villain, a British member of parliament said on Wednesday.

The Oscar-sweeping Hollywood movie showed the Titanic’s first officer, William Murdoch, taking a bribe, shooting a third-class passenger who tried to fight his way into a lifeboat and then turning his gun on himself.

20th Century Fox admitted in a letter to Alisdair Morgan, the member of parliament for Murdoch’s hometown Dalbeattie, that it had no evidence the first officer of the fated ship had done any of those things.

The film maker also donated $8,340 to a memorial fund set up in Murdoch’s honor.

A copy of the letter was made available to Reuters, but there was no immediate comment from 20th Century Fox.

Titanic historians say that Murdoch did his utmost to save passengers, guiding them into boats and then throwing deck chairs overboard for those in the sea to cling to. He drowned when the ship went down.

In the sea-faring town of Dalbeattie, Murdoch’s heroism is honored with a plaque on the town hall and there was outrage at the portrayal of him in the film.

“As a Scotsman myself and one who has spent some of the best days of my life in the heart of Dalbeattie, no one is more interested in setting the record straight about one of its citizens than I am,” 20th Century Fox’s Executive Vice President, Scott Neeson, wrote to Morgan. But Neeson said Dalbeattie had misunderstood the film-maker’s intention to show Murdoch as “one of the most humane, selfless and sensitively drawn characters.”

Director James Cameron had meant the audience to understand that Murdoch was disgusted by the attempt to bribe him and killed himself in remorse over his panic shooting of the belligerent passenger, Neeson said.

Records dating from the disaster put on display Wednesday by Britain’s Public Record Office show that Titanic survivors were impressed by the cool behavior of the crew.

“Nothing but the most heroic conduct; perfectly orderly,” a survivor named “Gracie” told a U.S. Congress inquiry in 1912.

“They showed very good judgment … they were very cool,” said another survivor, identified only as Stengel.

Around 1,500 people died when the Titanic went down in 1912 after striking an iceberg.

The public records suggest another inaccuracy in the film — the scenes showing third-class passengers being barred from reaching the upper decks where the lifeboats were being loaded.

The official inquiry showed that third-class passengers had not been prevented from leaving their quarters and suggested that many were reluctant to leave, believing the ship to be unsinkable. REUTERS@

Share the love!

2 Comments on ‘Titanic’ Makers Apologize to Hero’s Hometown

  1. Aime
    August 16, 2010 at 1:39 pm (4 years ago)

    Apart from having some lovely costumes this is an awful film, absolute drivel.

    Reply
    • Jennie Chancey
      August 16, 2010 at 8:23 pm (4 years ago)

      I couldn’t agree with you MORE, Aime! Terrible, terrible film. The costumes were the one reason I went to see it. It was so vastly disappointing on so many levels. Special effects cannot make up for a ridiculous storyline and bad writing. Thanks for leaving a note!

      Reply

Leave a Reply